2026-10-08FR-AM-0002Second-cycle Legacy Provenance Review completed as PASS across all five existing evidence instances. Underlying sources and claim representation verified; existing structured provenance is sufficient and no unverifiable attribution was introduced. No factual, interpretive, attribution, or verification-stage discrepancy identified. No genuinely new scientific evidence admitted or flagged for Normal Record Review. Canonical outcome verified / not_required; Pressure State and Verification Stage unchanged.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-07FR-AM-0001Second-cycle Legacy Provenance Review completed as PASS across all nine existing evidence instances. Underlying sources and claim representation verified; existing structured provenance is sufficient and no unverifiable attribution was introduced. No factual, interpretive, attribution, or verification-stage discrepancy identified. No genuinely new scientific evidence admitted or flagged for Normal Record Review. Canonical outcome verified / not_required; Pressure State and Verification Stage unchanged.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-06FR-AI-0009Operator-approved bounded correction to IN-006. RoboWM-Bench wording narrowed from language implying physical-robot execution to simulation-based embodied executability in physically grounded / real-to-sim environments. IN-006 ID and evidential vector preserved; no assessment, Pressure State, Verification Stage, mechanism, lineage or open question changed.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-10-06FR-AI-0009Second-cycle Legacy Provenance Review completed across all nine existing evidence instances. Eight instances verified source-faithful; IN-006 requires operator-approved bounded correction because current wording can imply physical-robot validation whereas RoboWM-Bench v2 validates generated behaviours through physically grounded simulation / real-to-sim execution. No correction applied through LPR-001. No genuinely new scientific evidence admitted or flagged for Normal Record Review. Canonical outcome review_required / pending; Pressure State and Verification Stage unchanged.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-05FR-AM-0008Legacy Provenance Review completed as PASS across both existing evidence instances. Underlying sources and claim representation verified; existing structured provenance is sufficient and no unverifiable attribution was introduced. No factual, interpretive, attribution, or verification-stage discrepancy identified. No genuinely new scientific evidence admitted or flagged for Normal Record Review. Canonical outcome verified / not_required; Pressure State and Verification Stage unchanged.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-04FR-QE-0001Build-contract repair: normalized the unsupported review marker to the governed value consistent with M-008. The D37 discrepancy remains pending; no evidence correction, assessment change, or review completion is implied.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-10-04FR-AI-0006Build-contract repair: normalized the unsupported D36 PASS marker to the governed completed-review value. M-020 records a passing re-audit following the earlier M-012 bounded correction; explicit unresolved IN-005 provenance debt remains. No evidence, assessment, review date, or repair status changed.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-10-04FR-AI-0008Second-cycle Legacy Provenance Review completed as PASS across all six existing evidence instances. Current source-to-claim representations remain source-faithful after the governed D08 correction and subsequent Normal Record Review of IN-006. IN-005 remains explicit unsupported legacy provenance debt and is already withdrawn from the current evidential basis, so no source was guessed or retrofitted. No factual, interpretive, attribution, or verification-stage discrepancy was identified; no genuinely new scientific evidence was admitted or flagged for Normal Record Review. Canonical outcome verified / not_required; Pressure State and Verification Stage unchanged.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-04FR-AM-0008Initial governed assessment: EMERGING / VS-02 — Published. Evidence concentration and intrinsic-origin tests limit posture; no independent audit or replication inferred from publication count.assessment_issuedA
2026-10-04FR-AM-0008Historical baseline and 2026 experimental source family logged with structured provenance. Earlier 2022 disclosure retained without duplicate independent weight; no media-only evidence event.instances_loggedA
2026-10-04FR-AM-0008Operator-authorised bounded admission following Materials Scout and new-record review. Scope and MC-01–MC-04 retained in docs/reviews/ADMISSION-2026-10-04-FR-AM-0008.md; no existing record reassessed.record_createdA
2026-10-03FR-QE-0002Operator-approved bounded correction of the five legacy source-representation discrepancies carried from D14 and reconfirmed by D39. IN-001 corrects the 2013 transaction to USRA leasing the D-Wave system within the NASA/Google/USRA collaboration and bounds the 2014 benchmark conclusion. IN-002 replaces the erroneous 108-qubit framing with the D-Wave 2X weak-strong-cluster benchmark up to 945 variables and preserves the source's comparator limits. IN-003 removes the categorical performance conclusion not established by Yarkoni et al. and represents that work as an industry-applications review. IN-004 corrects Nature to Nature Physics, the model to a one-dimensional transverse-field Ising chain, and removes the unsupported classical-inaccessibility claim. IN-005 bounds the 2023 result to 3D spin-glass dynamics and analogous Monte Carlo comparators and removes the unsourced critics assertion. Structured sources added where attribution is established. IN-006, assessments, Pressure State and Verification Stage unchanged.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-10-03FR-QE-0002Second-cycle Legacy Provenance Review completed. Six current instances examined. IN-006 verified. Five previously identified D14 representation discrepancies remain pending governed correction; no discrepant wording was changed and no provenance was attached where that would endorse the current representation. No instance was provenance-unverifiable. No new scientific evidence was admitted or flagged for Normal Record Review. Outcome remains discrepancies_found / pending; Pressure State and Verification Stage unchanged.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-03FR-QE-0008Normal Record Review of RR-2026-10-03-01 admitted Burt et al., arXiv:2610.01923v1, as distinct protocol-design evidence for loss-tolerant distributed lattice surgery. The 50% interface-erasure result assumes absent local noise; local errors mask the interface-distance advantage at 10^-3 circuit/resource error and gains strengthen at lower noise. This is not an experimental system-scale suppression result. AS-003 remains current; FR-QE-0008 stays RESOLVING / VS-04. No open question or claim change.instance_appendedA
2026-10-03FR-AI-0007Normal Record Review of flag 2026-10-03-02 appended AS-004 following operator decision to add the suggested assessment. ScholarCatalyst adds bounded benchmark evidence about author-judged literature selection and scientific judgment (894 queries; 184 lead authors; agentic R@20 0.42 vs strongest embedding 0.48). Retrieval is not end-to-end discovery, and CS-only coverage, retrospective labels and unknown performance ceiling are retained as limits. FRAGMENTING / VS-03 retained; no new instance, claim, mechanism, open question or verification-stage change.assessment_appendedUNKNOWN
2026-10-03FR-AI-0007Second-cycle Legacy Provenance Review completed as PASS across all nine existing evidence instances. IN-001 through IN-004 and IN-006 through IN-009 remain source-faithful; DOI metadata was added to the four already-structured Nature sources where canonical identifiers are confidently established. IN-005 remains explicit unresolved legacy provenance debt and is already withdrawn from the current evidential basis, so no source was guessed or retrofitted. No factual, interpretive, attribution, or verification-stage discrepancy was identified; no genuinely new scientific evidence was admitted or flagged for Normal Record Review. Canonical outcome verified / not_required; Pressure State and Verification Stage unchanged.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-02FR-AI-0005Legacy Provenance Review completed as PASS across all seven existing evidence instances. Seven were source-verifiable; no structured-source enrichment was required; no instance was unverifiable; no factual, interpretive, attribution, or verification-stage discrepancy was identified; and no genuinely new scientific evidence required routing to Normal Record Review. Canonical governed outcome recorded as verified / not_required. Completion marker advances the deterministic provenance-review queue.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-02FR-AI-0005Legacy Provenance Review completed as PASS. All seven existing evidence instances were re-audited against their attributed underlying sources and remained materially source-faithful. Verified: 7; enriched: 0; unverifiable: 0; discrepancies: 0; Normal Record Review candidates: 0. No evidence, assessment, pressure-state or verification-stage change made. Canonical governed outcome stored as verified / not_required.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-01FR-QE-0001Legacy Provenance Review completed across all six existing evidence instances. IN-001, IN-002, IN-003, IN-005 and IN-006 remain materially source-faithful. IN-004 has a bounded source-representation discrepancy: Zhao et al. directly support 1,432 GPUs, uncorrelated samples, higher XEB and sevenfold faster time-to-solution than Sycamore, but the record additionally states that the comparison used substantially greater energy consumption than the quantum device; the cited paper instead emphasizes improved classical energy efficiency relative to prior classical simulations and does not support that specific quantum-device energy comparison in the represented source text. No silent repair made; correction pending operator approval. A separate 2025 Sycamore-class simulation was surfaced as a Normal Record Review candidate and not admitted through LPR-001. Completion marker recorded so the deterministic queue advances.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-01FR-AI-0006LPR-001-D36 completed as PASS after bounded re-audit of all seven then-existing evidence instances. Six were source-verifiable; IN-005 remained explicit unresolved legacy provenance debt with no guessed source. No new legacy discrepancy required correction. A genuinely new Keeman (2026) candidate was routed to Normal Record Review rather than admitted through LPR-001 and was subsequently resolved as IN-008 / AS-005. Completion marker advances the deterministic provenance-review queue.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-10-01FR-AI-0006Normal Record Review reassessed FR-AI-0006 after admission of IN-008. Keeman adds bounded cross-scale continuity evidence but does not resolve mechanism identity. FRAGMENTING / VS-03 retained; preprint, replication, family/training and non-emergence limitations recorded.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-10-01FR-AI-0006Normal Record Review admitted Keeman (2026), arXiv:2603.22295v1, as bounded evidence that affect-reception representations recur across six Llama/Gemma base and instruct variants while emotion categorisation improves with scale. Primary provenance recorded; no legacy instance altered.instance_addedA
2026-09-30FR-AI-0004Governed bounded correction applied to IN-002 after LPR-001-D35. Brown et al. remains strong supportive evidence for task-agnostic few-shot/in-context performance without task-specific parameter updates, but the description no longer asserts that the paper proves the evaluated tasks were absent from GPT-3 pretraining. Existing BN-001 contamination/task-novelty qualification is preserved. No new evidence admitted; claim statement, assessments, pressure state, and verification stage unchanged. LPR-001-D35 completion recorded so the provenance-review queue may advance.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-29FR-AI-0001Normal Record Review, retrospective route authorized by operator. Added OpenAI-reported IMO 2025 gold-medal-level performance as bounded supportive evidence, with first-party retrospective reporting and official IMO gold threshold provenance. Limitations on independent score validation and evaluation detail are explicit. Claim, historical assessments, current ESCALATING / VS-03 state, mechanisms and open questions unchanged.instances_appendedUNKNOWN
2026-09-29FR-AI-0001Operator-approved bounded correction completed. IN-003 now labels the unattributed GPT-4/IMO/AIME account as an unverified legacy report and no longer presents it as supportive evidence; no source was inferred. IN-006 now distinguishes behavioral chain-of-thought faithfulness studies from Lindsey et al.'s mechanistic-interpretability analysis, narrows the evidence's relation to OQ-002, and reflects the 2023–25 source chronology. Existing structured sources remain. Historical assessments, pressure state ESCALATING, verification stage VS-03, mechanisms, lineage and open questions remain unchanged. No new evidence was admitted.provenance_repairUNKNOWN
2026-09-29FR-AI-0002Approved bounded correction and closure of the second-cycle provenance review. IN-003 narrowed to attributable 2023 legal deployment without an unmeasured time-saving claim; IN-005 aligned to the 2025 QJE sample, 15% productivity result and distinct sentiment versus surveyed-satisfaction outcomes; IN-006 narrowed to SWE-bench and SWE-agent results without an unsupported human baseline or broad agent-failure claims. Structured primary sources added; lineage date aligned. AS-001 and AS-002 preserved as dated historical assessments, with no new scientific evidence, pressure-state or verification-stage change.provenance_review_completedD
2026-09-29FR-AI-0003Bounded correction completed for IN-007 and IN-009. IN-007 now limits ROGUE to task-specific computer-use corrigibility evidence and removes the unsupported direct link to RLHF preference generalisation or causal capability effects. IN-009 corrects the author-affiliation description and identifies public/OTR divergence as observable channel-conditioned output, not hidden belief or established strategy. Append-only AS-004 clarifies the current source-to-claim interpretation while preserving FRAGMENTING / VS-03 and all historical assessments. No evidence was admitted; claim and open questions unchanged.provenance_repairUNKNOWN
2026-09-28FR-AI-0009Bounded reassessment after IN-009 and Worldmodeldata–Mila research-plan review. Task-specific game-to-robot support is recognized; commercial game-data transfer remains unvalidated. ESCALATING / VS-02 held. OQ-006 records the controlled comparison needed.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-09-28FR-AI-0009IN-009 Project Kitchen / Game2Policy preprint added as qualified, task-specific game-to-robot transfer evidence. WIRED coverage and the Worldmodeldata–Mila planned study were not treated as demonstrated transfer results.instance_addedA
2026-09-28FR-BT-0007Legacy provenance review completed. All seven existing instances verified against their structured sources; no provenance enrichment, discrepancy or new-evidence candidate identified. No assessment, interpretation, pressure state, verification stage, mechanism, attractor or claim changed.provenance_review_completedD
2026-09-27FR-BT-0006Legacy provenance review completed. All four existing instances verified against their structured sources; no provenance enrichment, discrepancy or new-evidence candidate identified. No assessment, interpretation, pressure state, verification stage, mechanism, attractor or claim changed.provenance_review_completedD
2026-09-26FR-QE-0008Bounded consistency correction after the Helios Normal Record Review: RM-001 now distinguishes observed repetition-code floors in IN-005 from unresolved larger-distance surface-code and full-circuit behaviour, and states threshold assumptions accurately. AT-001 treats distance-9/11 experiments as informative tests, not an automatic or universal confirmation rule. No instance, assessment, pressure state, verification stage, open question, or claim was changed.mechanism_attractor_consistency_correctedUNKNOWN
2026-09-26FR-QE-0008Normal Record Review of RR-2026-09-05-01 admitted Berthusen et al., arXiv:2609.03194v1, as distinct trapped-ion architecture evidence. The reported logical QEC cycle, Clifford benchmark and surface-code interface do not establish increasing-distance suppression, independent replication or useful fault-tolerant economics. AS-003 remains derived current assessment at RESOLVING / VS-04. The retrospectively incomplete Scout stated 4 September as first public date; arXiv v1 was submitted 2 September 2026, inside its review window.instance_appendedA
2026-09-26FR-AI-0002Normal Record Review of Frontline Scout flag 2026-09-26-01 admitted OSWorld-Pro arXiv:2609.24890v1 as bounded process-level contesting evidence at the low-supervision agentic boundary. AS-002 remains current; Pressure State ESCALATING, Verification Stage VS-02, mechanisms and open questions unchanged. The benchmark does not establish economic productivity or real-world supervision cost.instance_appendedA
2026-09-26FR-BT-0004Normal Record Review of the two LPR-001-D28 new-evidence candidates. Peer-reviewed NHS-Galleri primary RCT and three-round performance papers admitted as IN-007 and IN-008. Evidence quality and test-performance characterization strengthened; mortality and overdiagnosis remain unresolved; AT-001 unsatisfied.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-09-26FR-BT-0004Normal Record Review admitted Sasieni et al. NEJM doi:10.1056/NEJMoa2505723 as IN-007 and Neal et al. Nature Medicine doi:10.1038/s41591-026-04652-8 as IN-008. These were held outside LPR-001-D28 until normal review.instances_loggedA
2026-09-26FR-BT-0004Approved bounded LPR-001 correction. IN-001 date scope corrected from 2014–19 to 2008–19 to include the cited Diehl et al. 2008 foundation. IN-003 participant count corrected from 142,924 enrolled to 142,250 randomised, with arm counts 71,122 and 71,128, matching the peer-reviewed NHS-Galleri result. No new scientific evidence admitted; September 2026 NHS-Galleri publications remain Normal Record Review candidates.provenance_review_completedD
2026-09-26FR-BT-0005Normal Record Review of the Lancet 271-day xenokidney case. Capability evidence strengthens and late microvascular/innate injury is better resolved, but prospective multi-recipient replication remains outstanding.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-09-26FR-BT-0005Riella et al., Lancet 2026, admitted as IN-008 after being held outside LPR-001-D29. IN-003 retained as historical chronology rather than overwritten.instances_loggedA
2026-09-26FR-BT-0005Legacy provenance review completed. All seven existing instances verified against underlying or authoritative sources; structured sources[] added where attribution was confidently established. No factual, interpretive, attribution or verification-stage discrepancy identified. The September 2026 peer-reviewed Lancet report of the 271-day case was held outside LPR-001 as a Normal Record Review candidate.provenance_review_completedD
2026-09-25FR-BT-0003Normal Record Review admitted Oh et al., Nature Medicine 2025, DOI 10.1038/s41591-025-03798-1, with structured primary provenance. In 44,498 UK Biobank participants, 11 organ-specific age estimates derived from 2,916 plasma proteins were associated with subsequent disease and mortality over 2–17 years. This strengthens prospective organ-specific blood evidence beyond the 2023 study but does not establish externally calibrated individual absolute risk, transportable performance or clinical benefit from acting on a score. AS-003 appended with no pressure-state or stage transition. BN-001, RM-001 and AT-001 sharpened; lineage extended. LPR-001-D27 marker and historical assessments retained unchanged.record_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-25FR-BT-0003Approved bounded correction of IN-002 through IN-005. Lehallier's cross-sectional age-associated plasma proteome was separated from prospective outcome claims; Ahadi ageotypes distinguished from Oh's organ-specific plasma-protein models; DunedinPACE dated to 2022 with group-level outcome associations distinguished from clinical utility; InnerAge blood, Index saliva and TallyAge cheek-swab specimens corrected. IN-001 remained as audited. AS-001 preserved and AS-002 appended. BN-001, AT-001, lineage and OQ-001/OQ-002 aligned where they repeated withdrawn premises. FRAGMENTING / VS-03 retained on the narrower individual prospective-validation question. No 2025+ scientific evidence admitted.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-24FR-BT-0002Approved bounded correction of IN-001, IN-003, IN-004 and IN-005. Separated 2006 iPSC induction from later in-vitro epigenetic-clock findings; corrected Yamanaka's Altos role and limited funding to its sourced commitment; replaced the unsupported clock-intervention attribution with identifiable 2024 studies and their publication class; narrowed the primate evidence to Life Biosciences' 2024 company-reported ocular model. IN-002 was enriched from verified Ocampo and Lu papers. IN-006 and IN-007 were preserved. AS-004 appended; RM-001, lineage and OQ-001 aligned with corrected evidence. ESCALATING / VS-02 retained. No later scientific evidence admitted.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-23FR-BT-0001Normal Record Review of Bian et al. (2026), EBioMedicine 124:106124, DOI 10.1016/j.ebiom.2026.106124. The primary study reports D+Q effects in streptozotocin-induced diabetic male C57BL/6J mice and supporting cell models; it is admitted as disease-specific preclinical evidence. It reports no new human intervention result or hard human healthspan outcome. AS-003 is appended with no state change: ESCALATING / VS-02 retained. The review is separate from LPR-001-D25 and does not alter its provenance-correction outcome.instance_addedA
2026-09-23FR-BT-0001Approved bounded correction of IN-001 through IN-005. IN-001 now states the source-supported, sex- and background-dependent mouse lifespan result; IN-002 separates the 2019 IPF and diabetic-kidney-disease D+Q pilots; IN-003 corrects Unity chronology and distinguishes UBX0101 from company-reported UBX1325 eye-disease evidence; IN-004 withdraws the mismatched MILES/AFFIRM-NASH/Müller trial bundle; and IN-005 bounds broader longevity-sector interest as non-efficacy context. Structured sources[] added only where the reviewed source basis is confident. AS-001 is preserved and AS-002 appended; RM-001, lineage and OQ-001 were aligned. ESCALATING / VS-02 retained. No 2026 evidence admitted; the diabetic-kidney-disease report remains a Normal Record Review candidate.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-23FR-BT-0001Legacy provenance review completed. All five instances require bounded correction before structured sources[] can be attached without endorsing inaccurate or conflated wording. IN-001 overstates Baker et al.'s 2016 median-lifespan result as approximately 25%; the reported extension varies by sex and genetic background. IN-002 conflates the 2019 open-label IPF D+Q pilot (physical-function feasibility signal) with the separate 2019 diabetic-kidney-disease preliminary report (adipose/epidermal senescent-cell measures); it misattributes authorship, study design, tissue measures, and functional outcomes. IN-003 misdates the UBX0101 Phase II result and compresses distinct company-reported UBX1325 outcomes into a mixed 2022–23 clinical-failure narrative. IN-004 relies on a mismatched MILES trial (sirolimus in lymphangioleiomyomatosis, not D+Q senolysis) and cannot establish the claimed AFFIRM-NASH/Müller D+Q biomarker result. IN-005 conflates broad longevity-sector capital, which is not necessarily senolytic investment, with evidence for this claim. No evidence wording, assessment, pressure state, verification stage, mechanisms, lineage, or open questions was silently changed. A 2026 pilot report of D+Q in diabetic kidney disease is held out as a normal Record Review candidate and not admitted through LPR-001.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-22FR-AM-0007Approved bounded correction of IN-002. Replaced the unsupported 2022–24 subsequent-extension chronology with the source-faithful 2021 same-study FeSe/Cu-doped-FeSe comparison; added the primary PNAS provenance; and aligned the dependent 2022–24 lineage wording. Consistency review confirms AS-001, ESCALATING / VS-03, mechanisms, attractors, and open questions remain valid because the record's cross-material trajectory is independently carried by Sb, Bi0.5Sb1.5Te3, and Hg1223 evidence. No new evidence admitted.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-22FR-AM-0007Legacy provenance review completed. IN-001, IN-003 and IN-004 were verified against the named peer-reviewed primary papers and received structured sources[]. IN-002 requires bounded correction before provenance can be attached: its characterisation of Cu-doped FeSe as a subsequent 2022–24 cross-material extension is chronologically inaccurate, because Cu-doped FeSe is reported alongside pure FeSe in the 2021 PNAS pressure-quench paper. The core pressure-quench trajectory and the current AS-001 state are not silently changed. No new evidence admitted through LPR-001.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-21FR-QE-0008Structural chronology repair: restored assessments[] to the canonical oldest-first order after AS-002 and AS-003 were mistakenly prepended on 2026-09-18. Existing assessment objects, dates, wording, pressure states, verification stages and evidentiary judgements are unchanged. This correction restores AS-003 as the derived current assessment and makes the repair explicit in the append-only mutation history.assessment_order_correctedUNKNOWN
2026-09-21FR-AM-0006LPR-001-D23 completed. Corrected QuantumScape's 2021 independent-test characterisation, Toyota's June 2023 roadmap parameters, unbounded Argonne/Fraunhofer attribution, and unsupported Chinese production, pilot, and supply-chain assertions. State remains ESCALATING and current verification stage remains VS-02; no new evidence admitted.provenance_repairUNKNOWN
2026-09-20FR-AM-0005Bounded correction executed for IN-001 through IN-006. Retracted-paper descriptions were narrowed to the retraction findings; LK-99 was corrected to candidate-specific failed replication; hydride context was source-bounded; the unsupported universal three-signature rule and alleged editorial guidance were removed; post-LK-99 absence claims were narrowed; and IN-006 was corrected for publication/preprint dates, the LaSc₂H₂₄ paper's reported measurements and its unreplicated status, with the unverified PNAS roadmap removed. Structured sources[] added to repaired instances. AS-001 and AS-002 preserved append-only; AS-003 explicitly re-evaluates and retains COLLAPSED / VS-05 on the narrower independent-reproducibility basis. CM-001, AT-001, 2020–23/2024–25 lineage, OQ-001 and OQ-004 brought into consistency. No new evidence admitted.provenance_repairUNKNOWN
2026-09-20FR-AM-0005Bounded provenance audit completed for IN-001 through IN-006. Material representation and attribution discrepancies identified; no material corrections applied. Routine structured-source enrichment withheld where the instance itself requires correction. Queue marker recorded so deterministic LPR selection advances. Bounded correction candidate pending operator approval.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-19FR-AM-0004Bounded correction executed for IN-001 through IN-006. Corrected JET Q and event chronology; corrected NIF yield and target-gain arithmetic; removed the false OpenAI-backing attribution and unsupported revenue-guarantee characterization; separated ITER plasma Q from plant-level net electricity and updated the revised baseline; reconstructed the economic instance around traceable conditional studies; and corrected DOE roadmap participation figures. Structured sources[] added to all repaired instances. IN-007 passed unchanged. AS-001 and AS-002 preserved append-only; corrective AS-003 appended, with RM-001, the directly dependent 1997 and reviewed 2022 and 2023–24 lineage entries, and OQ-004 brought into consistency. Pressure State ESCALATING and Verification Stage VS-02 retained. JET's later 69.26 MJ result remains outside this correction for Normal Record Review.provenance_repairUNKNOWN
2026-09-18FR-QE-0008Normal Record Review admitted Sivak et al., Nature 655 (2026), reinforcement-learning control of QEC. Experimental Willow results show continuous syndrome-driven control improves logical stability against injected drift and supports uninterrupted calibration; distance-15 evidence is simulation only. AS-003 appended; RESOLVING / VS-04 retained. RM-001 and AT-001 consistency wording completed from the authorised LPR-001-D20 correction and updated to reflect that drift mitigation does not remove correlated-error floors or satisfy the outcome-based attractor.instance_appendedA
2026-09-18FR-QE-0008Bounded correction executed for IN-001 through IN-005. Corrected the 2023 distance-3/5 numerical representation; corrected Willow suppression semantics to Λ per distance increase of two; separated Microsoft/Quantinuum trapped-ion evidence from Microsoft's topological programme; replaced unsupported generic logical-gate rates; and corrected the correlated-error-floor representation using observed repetition-code floors. Structured sources[] added to all repaired instances. AS-001 preserved append-only and corrective AS-002 appended; RM-001, AT-001 and lineage brought into consistency. Pressure State RESOLVING and Verification Stage VS-04 retained. The 2026 reinforcement-learning QEC candidate remains outside this repair for Normal Record Review.provenance_repairUNKNOWN
2026-09-18FR-QE-0008LPR-001-D20 audited all five evidence instances. Material representation or attribution discrepancies require bounded correction in IN-001 through IN-005; no evidentiary prose was silently repaired and no structured sources were added where the representation itself requires correction. New 2026 QEC work was screened separately and not admitted through LPR-001.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-17FR-QE-0007LPR-001-D19 bounded correction: repaired IN-003, IN-004 and IN-006; added confidently established structured provenance; separated IBM's tested classical-comparison boundary from stronger legacy claims; separated Google's random-circuit-sampling evidence from the distinct Willow surface-code result and attributed company benchmark estimates; reconstructed the Quantum Echoes source chain and scale boundary; narrowed RM-001; generalised AT-001 to the claim's actual conjunction; repaired lineage; and appended AS-003 rather than rewriting historical assessments. The IBM/University of Chicago 2026 hard-circuit result remains a separate Normal Record Review candidate. Pressure State remains FRAGMENTING; Verification Stage remains VS-03.provenance_correctedUNKNOWN
2026-09-17FR-QE-0007LPR-001-D19 audited all six evidence instances. IN-001, IN-002 and IN-005 were substantially verified against their cited source chains; IN-003 and IN-004 contain overbroad or conflated classical-comparison/Willow representations; IN-006 contains a source-chain and representation package requiring bounded reconstruction before structured provenance is added. One new Normal Record Review candidate was surfaced: IBM and University of Chicago, Sampling hard circuits with verifiably high fidelity (30 July 2026); it was not admitted through LPR-001.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-16FR-QE-0006Normal Record Review admitted Proctor et al. QUOPS (arXiv:2609.12146) as supportive system-level gap-measurement evidence. Added IN-007 and AS-004 and updated current mechanisms and lineage to recognise the benchmark while preserving the application-specific classical-comparator requirement. QUOPS measures present physical and small logical processors and maps recognised challenge workloads into the same capability framework; its FeMoco translation remains about five orders of magnitude beyond present measured circuit-size capability. It does not demonstrate practical quantum advantage. ESCALATING / VS-02 reaffirmed. LPR-001-D18 remains completed.record_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-16FR-QE-0006LPR-001-D18 bounded correction: repaired IN-001 through IN-005, added confidently established structured provenance, corrected dependent mechanisms and lineage, and appended AS-003. IN-006 retained as verified. QUOPS remained a separate Normal Record Review candidate. Pressure State remains ESCALATING; Verification Stage remains VS-02.provenance_correctedUNKNOWN
2026-09-16FR-QE-0006LPR-001-D18 audited all six evidence instances. IN-006 was source-verified and provenance-enriched. IN-001 through IN-005 required bounded correction. QUOPS surfaced as a Normal Record Review candidate.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-15FR-QE-0005Normal Record Review admitted two 2026 RSA-2048 resource analyses: IN-007 Webster et al. Pinnacle QLDPC architecture and IN-008 Mundada et al. heterogeneous architecture. Appended AS-004 and updated current mechanisms, lineage and open questions to distinguish architecture-dependent theoretical resource compression from demonstrated cryptographic capability. Pressure state remains ESCALATING; verification stage remains VS-02.instances_loggedA
2026-09-15FR-QE-0005LPR-001-D17 bounded correction: repaired IN-001 through IN-006, added confidently established structured provenance, corrected dependent mechanisms, lineage and open-question wording, and appended AS-003 rather than rewriting historical assessments. Removed unreviewed 2026 QLDPC/ECC material from legacy IN-006 so it can be handled through normal Record Review. Pressure state remains ESCALATING; verification stage remains VS-02.provenance_correctedUNKNOWN
2026-09-15FR-AI-0009Bounded provenance-display correction: the DOI already preserved in IN-001's legacy sourceReference was added to the corresponding structured source so the public Evidence Sources rendering retains it. Citation, URL, locator, evidence wording and assessment are unchanged.reference_correctedD
2026-09-15FR-BT-0007Admission diagnosis: EMERGING / VS-03. Communication capability is independently demonstrated and one participant has sustained everyday use; cross-participant operational replication remains absent.diagnosis_heldA (subsumed)
2026-09-15FR-BT-0007BN-001, RM-001, RM-002, RM-003 and AT-001 recorded from the admission evidence package.mechanisms_recordedA (subsumed)
2026-09-15FR-BT-0007AS-001 issued. Pressure State: EMERGING. Verification Stage: VS-03.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-09-15FR-BT-0007IN-001 through IN-007 admitted as the initial evidence set with source-level structured provenance.instances_loggedA
2026-09-14FR-QE-0004Operator-approved bounded repair completed for all four discrepancies identified by LPR-001-D16. IN-001 narrowed from an unsupported heterogeneous 2014–19 synthesis to the sourceable Barends et al. 2014 superconducting gate-threshold result and received structured provenance. IN-002 corrected to Ryan-Anderson et al. 2021 [[7,1,3]] colour-code evidence: logical SPAM below physical SPAM is retained, while the unsupported claim that the overall system crossed the pseudo-threshold is removed; structured provenance added. IN-003 corrected from a misdated generic approximately 10^-4 two-qubit logical-gate claim to the April 2024 Microsoft/Quantinuum interested-party report of four logical qubits, up to 800x logical-versus-physical suppression and more than 14,000 circuit instances without an observed error; company-source provenance and evidentiary boundary recorded. IN-005 corrected to the February 2025 Nature parity-measurement experiment and explicitly bounded as contextual topological-platform evidence, not a protected logical-qubit or below-threshold demonstration; structured provenance added. Consistency review found AS-001's historical warrant depended materially on the old IN-002/IN-003 representations, so AS-001 was preserved unchanged and corrective AS-004 appended; current RESOLVING / VS-04 remains independently supported by IN-004 and later evidence. Lineage corrected to match the repaired chronology and evidentiary boundaries. RM-001, AT-001 and OQ-001–OQ-003 remain valid and unchanged. provenanceOutcome advanced to pass_after_correction and provenanceRepairStatus to completed.provenance_repairUNKNOWN
2026-09-14FR-QE-0004Normal Record Review completed for Paetznick et al., Nature 654, 349–355 (2026), DOI 10.1038/s41586-026-10628-y. IN-010 admitted as strong SUPPORTIVE evidence: trapped-ion fault-tolerant circuits using 12-qubit/two-logical-qubit and 16-qubit/four-logical-qubit code constructions achieved 11x–800x logical error-rate improvements relative to corresponding physical-circuit baselines. The evidentiary boundary explicitly retains the role of error detection and post-selection and does not reinterpret the experiment as code-distance scaling. AS-003 appended: RESOLVING / VS-04 reaffirmed because the result strengthens multi-platform and multi-code evidence but does not satisfy OQ-001's governed d=11-and-above scaling criterion. 2026 lineage extended. LPR-001-D16 discrepancies in IN-001, IN-002, IN-003 and IN-005 remain pending and were not repaired through this Record Review.record_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-14FR-QE-0004Legacy provenance review completed. All nine evidence instances examined. Structured sources[] were added only to cleanly sourceable IN-004, IN-006, IN-007, and IN-009; IN-008 already carried structured provenance and was verified. Four legacy discrepancy candidates require governed correction before provenance can be attached without endorsing problematic wording: IN-001 compresses heterogeneous 2014–19 QEC work into a broad surface-code/superconducting-and-trapped-ion synthesis that could not be confidently reconstructed from a single contemporaneous source chain; IN-002 is misdated to 2022 and overstates Ryan-Anderson et al. 2021, whose [[7,1,3]] colour-code result achieved logical SPAM below physical SPAM but did not establish that the overall error-correction system had crossed the pseudo-threshold; IN-003 is misdated to 2023 and states an approximately 10^-4 per two-qubit logical-gate metric not supported by the later peer-reviewed Microsoft/Quantinuum evidence; IN-005 is dated 2024 despite describing an early-2025 announcement and overstates Microsoft's 2025 parity-readout/topological programme as demonstrating below-physical-rate logical-qubit operation, whereas the Nature paper explicitly states its measurement does not by itself determine whether the low-energy states are topological. No discrepant wording, assessment, pressureState, verificationStage, mechanisms, lineage, or open questions were silently changed. One normal Record Review candidate was flagged and not admitted through LPR-001: Paetznick et al., Nature 654, 349–355 (2026), DOI 10.1038/s41586-026-10628-y, reporting 11x–800x logical error-rate improvements on Quantinuum trapped-ion hardware relative to physical circuit baselines.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-13FR-QE-0003Legacy provenance review completed. All six evidence instances examined. IN-005 and IN-006 were cleanly provenance-enriched with the peer-reviewed Willow Nature source. Four material discrepancy candidates require governed correction before provenance can be attached without endorsing legacy wording. IN-001 incorrectly describes the 2021 repetition-code experiment as a surface-code implementation and confuses physical-qubit count with code distance: the experiment used repetition codes from d=3 to d=11, corresponding to 5 to 21 qubits, while the surface-code test was only d=2. IN-002 appears to conflate Quantinuum/Honeywell's 2021 real-time [[7,1,3]] colour-code QEC result with later fault-tolerant gate demonstrations; the 2021 experiment reported logical SPAM below physical SPAM but explicitly had not reached the overall error-correction threshold, so the present 2022 gate-level below-physical claim is not source-faithful as written. IN-003 overstates the 2023 Google Nature result: that experiment compared d=3 with d=5 on a 72-qubit device and achieved only a modest roughly 4% relative logical-error reduction, not d=3/d=5/d=7 with roughly halving at each step; d=7 and >2x suppression arrived with Willow. IN-004 misstates the Microsoft/Quantinuum 2024 result as approximately 10^-4 per two-qubit logical gate. The contemporaneous work reported circuit-level logical error reductions, including Bell-state preparation down to about 10^-5 with post-selection and repeated-error-correction comparisons, not a generic per-two-qubit-logical-gate 10^-4 metric; its broader claim that the result was below thresholds generally required for useful FTQC is also not directly established by that source. No historical wording, assessment, pressure state, verification stage, mechanism, lineage, or open question was silently changed. No verified experimental d=11+ below-threshold surface-code result was found. The 28 April 2026 Nature Author Correction to the Willow paper changes figure labelling only and does not alter the evidence interpretation.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-12FR-QE-0002Governed normal Record Review completed for the two candidates surfaced by LPR-001-D14. Quinton et al., Scientific Reports 2025 (DOI 10.1038/s41598-025-96220-2), is admitted as IN-006 because it directly benchmarks a D-Wave hybrid quantum-annealing workflow against CPLEX, Gurobi and IPOPT on optimisation tasks. Its result is mixed and bounded: advantage for the studied BQP cases, but no general advantage across tested classes and no superiority over Gurobi on the unit-commitment case. King et al., Science 2025 (DOI 10.1126/science.ado6285), is not admitted as an evidence instance: despite strong beyond-classical quantum-simulation results, it studies dynamical quantum simulation rather than an optimisation task and therefore fails the settled optimisation-task element of this record's identity-bearing kernel. AS-003 appended; FRAGMENTING / VS-03 reaffirmed; lineage extended. LPR-001-D14 legacy discrepancies remain pending and were not altered by this Record Review.record_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-12FR-QE-0002Legacy provenance review completed. All five evidence instances examined and each contains at least one source-fidelity, attribution, chronology, or interpretive issue requiring governed correction before structured sources[] can be attached without endorsing legacy wording. IN-001 inaccurately frames the 2013 D-Wave Two transaction as a sale to Google/NASA/USRA collectively; contemporaneous reporting identifies USRA as purchaser with Google and NASA collaborators. IN-002's qualified event incorrectly says 108-qubit while Denchev et al. studied D-Wave 2X instances up to 945 variables, and the legacy wording strengthens the source-supported claim that specialist classical heuristics are comparable into a broader match-or-exceed assertion. IN-003 attributes a categorical cross-instance performance conclusion to Yarkoni et al. 2022 that the review does not state in that form. IN-004 misidentifies the journal as Nature rather than Nature Physics, describes the system as a frustrated Ising spin glass rather than a one-dimensional transverse-field Ising chain, and attributes an inaccessibility claim not made by the paper. IN-005 overgeneralises the 2023 Nature result from scaling advantage against analogous Monte Carlo dynamics into a broader all-classical computational-advantage formulation and carries an unsourced critic-comparison assertion. No historical wording, assessment, pressure state, or verification stage was silently changed. Two post-baseline items were flagged for normal Record Review only: King et al., Science 2025, Beyond-classical computation in quantum simulation (DOI 10.1126/science.ado6285), and Quinton et al., Scientific Reports 2025, benchmarking D-Wave hybrid optimisation against CPLEX, Gurobi and IPOPT (DOI 10.1038/s41598-025-96220-2).provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-12FR-BT-0006Admission diagnosis: EMERGING / VS-02. Integrated cellular functions are established in peer-reviewed work; autonomous repeated reproduction remains provisional and unreplicated.diagnosis_heldA (subsumed)
2026-09-12FR-BT-0006BN-001, RM-001, RM-002, RM-003 and AT-001 recorded from the admission evidence package.mechanisms_recordedA (subsumed)
2026-09-12FR-BT-0006AS-001 issued. Pressure State: EMERGING. Verification Stage: VS-02.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-09-12FR-BT-0006IN-001 through IN-004 admitted as the initial evidence set with source-level structured provenance.instances_loggedA
2026-09-12FR-BT-0006FR-BT-0006 admitted following Biotechnology Programme Gap Review and formal New Record Evaluation.record_createdA
2026-09-11FR-QE-0001Legacy Provenance Review completed. All six evidence instances were audited against identifiable underlying sources and found materially faithful to those sources. Structured PA-002 sources[] were added for Arute et al. 2019, the contemporaneous IBM/Pednault rebuttal, Pan & Zhang 2021, Pan/Chen/Zhang 2022, Zhao et al. 2024, Google's Willow below-threshold error-correction paper, and Google's December 2024 Willow RCS announcement. No factual, interpretive, attribution, pressure-state or verification-stage discrepancy requiring governed correction was identified. The Willow 10^25-year classical estimate remains a claimant-produced estimate and, as represented in IN-006, has not been independently reproduced by a matching classical simulation. No new evidence was admitted and no normal Record Review candidate was generated by this provenance pass.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-10FR-AM-0003Governed Record Review admitted Radaelli et al. 2026 critical-spin-fluctuation evidence as IN-006 and Sordi et al. 2026 Hubbard-model pairing-dynamics evidence as IN-007. Append-only AS-003 records the combined assessment and reaffirms FRAGMENTING / VS-03. AT-001 was strengthened only to reflect the discriminating computational progress demonstrated by IN-007; lineage extended through 2026. Neither paper is treated as identifying the microscopic pairing mechanism in real cuprates.record_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-10FR-AM-0003Approved bounded provenance repair. Corrected IN-001 through IN-005 for source fidelity, chronology and mechanistic scope; added structured sources[] only for confidently established primary/review sources. Removed the categorical BCS/phonon exclusion from IN-001 and IN-003; narrowed IN-002 to Anderson's source-supported RVB proposal; removed categorical theory-exclusion claims from IN-004; corrected IN-005 chronology to 2015–24 and distinguished Hubbard-model benchmarking and cold-atom antiferromagnetism from direct reproduction of cuprate superconductivity. Append-only AS-002 reaffirms FRAGMENTING / VS-03 with corrected rationale; AS-001 remains intact as historical assessment. RM-002, BN-001, AT-001, lineage and OQ-001 were aligned to the corrected evidence semantics. No 2026 scientific evidence was admitted through this repair; previously flagged 2026 items remain normal Record Review candidates.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-10FR-AM-0003Legacy provenance review completed. All five evidence instances examined. Material source-fidelity or interpretive discrepancies identified in IN-001 through IN-005, so no structured sources were attached in a way that would endorse the legacy wording. IN-001 overstates the 1986 discovery as being above a defined BCS ceiling and as immediately excluding conventional electron-phonon physics; IN-002 mixes sourceable Anderson RVB history with broader unsourced chronology and vocabulary claims; IN-003 correctly records d-wave pairing symmetry but overstates it as ruling out phonon-mediated BCS pairing categorically; IN-004 combines sourceable pseudogap/CDW complexity and the Keimer review with overly categorical statements about what spin-fluctuation and RVB theories can accommodate; IN-005 misdates the Mazurenko 2017 cold-atom result inside a 2019–24 frame and overcompresses Simons/Hubbard benchmarking and what those studies establish about cuprate phenomenology. No factual, interpretive, assessment, pressure-state or verification-stage wording was silently changed. New 2026 work on critical spin fluctuations across LSCO and Hubbard-model pairing dynamics was flagged for normal Record Review and not admitted through LPR-001. Review marked pending governed correction.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-09FR-AM-0002Append-only AS-002 issued after the operator-approved LPR-001-D11 repair. FRAGMENTING / VS-03 retained on a narrower evidential basis. RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, the inherited-condition wording, lineage and OQ-001/OQ-002/OQ-004 were aligned to corrected source boundaries. Historical AS-001 preserved.assessment_and_dependencies_correctedA (subsumed)
2026-09-09FR-AM-0002Operator-approved correction of IN-001 through IN-005. Texas A&M attribution corrected; SRI loading correlation bounded to the programme's reported criterion; Storms reframed as a proponent review rather than validated protocol evidence; Berlinguette et al. corrected and the unsupported anomalous-calorimetry acknowledgement withdrawn; NASA/Navy bundle separated, with NASA lattice-confinement work treated as adjacent rather than direct excess-heat evidence. Structured provenance added where confidently established.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-09FR-AM-0002Legacy provenance review completed. All five evidence instances examined. Material source-fidelity or attribution discrepancies identified in IN-001 through IN-005, so no structured provenance was silently attached to those instances. IN-001 misattributes the Texas A&M 1989 excess-heat work to McKubre; IN-002's SRI loading-threshold core is sourceable but its decade-long/reproducibility and independent-replication framing requires bounding; IN-003's Storms protocol and comparative-success claims are more specific than the verified review evidence; IN-004 misattributes Berlinguette et al. and overstates the 2019 Google programme as acknowledging unexplained anomalous calorimetry; IN-005 conflates NASA/Navy programmes and incorrectly describes them as institutions with no prior LENR affiliation. No factual, interpretive, assessment, pressure-state or verification-stage wording changed. No sufficiently direct new scientific evidence was admitted; review marked pending governed correction.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-08FR-AM-0001Normal Record Review of IN-008 and IN-009. COLLAPSED / VS-05 retained. The new evidence positively establishes condensed-matter enhancement of externally driven low-energy fusion but does not satisfy the canonical electrochemical-cell-driven cold-fusion claim. OQ-002 and lineage updated to make the reopening boundary explicit; historical assessments and legacy instances preserved.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-09-08FR-AM-0001Normal Record Review admits Chen et al. (2025) and Karahadian et al. (2026) with primary provenance. Both are adjacent mechanistic evidence: electrochemical loading and condensed-matter environment measurably enhance D–D fusion under externally driven ion bombardment. Neither is treated as a qualifying reopening event for the canonical room-temperature electrochemical-fusion claim.instances_addedUNKNOWN
2026-09-08FR-AM-0001Append-only AS-004 issued after the operator-approved LPR-001-D10 repair. COLLAPSED / VS-05 retained on a narrower evidential basis. CM-001, affected lineage entries and OQ-001 aligned to the corrected provenance: public announcement timing is retained, unsupported institutional-pressure causation is withdrawn, Berlinguette attribution is corrected, and residual LENR questions are separated from evidence for the canonical fusion claim. Historical assessments preserved. The 2025–26 electrochemically assisted ion-beam fusion papers remain outside LPR-001 as normal Record Review candidates.assessment_and_dependencies_correctedA (subsumed)
2026-09-08FR-AM-0001Operator-approved correction of IN-001, IN-004, IN-005, IN-006 and IN-007. IN-001 bounded to the verified public-announcement/publication chronology; IN-004 aligned to the 1989 DOE panel's actual conclusions; IN-005 narrowed to documented persistence of LENR research without unsupported publication-practice claims; IN-006 separates the 2004 review's excess-power and nuclear-reaction reviewer distributions; IN-007 corrects Berlinguette et al. and removes the unsupported later NASA-adjacent bundle. Structured provenance added where source fidelity was established. No 2025–26 scientific evidence admitted through LPR-001.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-08FR-AM-0001Legacy provenance review completed. All seven evidence instances examined. Structured provenance added only to source-faithful early-replication instances IN-002 and IN-003. Material or attribution discrepancies identified in IN-001, IN-004, IN-006 and IN-007; IN-005's broad sociological and publication-practice bundle could not be confidently sourced as written. No factual or interpretive wording silently repaired and no assessment, pressure-state or verification-stage changes made. New 2025–26 electrochemically assisted ion-beam fusion results were identified as normal Record Review candidates and were not admitted through LPR-001. Review marked pending governed correction.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-07FR-AI-0009Legacy provenance review completed. All eight evidence instances examined and verified against their stated primary sources. Structured sources[] provenance added to IN-001 through IN-008 without changing evidence descriptions, vectors, assessment, pressure state, verification stage, mechanisms, lineage or open questions. No material discrepancies and no new scientific-evidence candidates were identified. Review outcome verified; repair not required.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-06FR-QE-0002Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002 from FR_QE_0002_DWave_frontier_record.html (Drive file 1s9-MAnWoWMwt2ReSLdPtGSW6QRtOVgvM). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-QE-0003Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, BN-001, AT-001; lineage 1995–96, 1998–2012, 2012–20 from FR_QE_0003_fault_tolerant_logical_qubits.html (Drive file 15wAwW5oDhl-eLUsK7g82KSR-0wJjufho). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-QE-0005Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, AT-001 from FR_QE_0005_RSA_quantum_factorisation.html (Drive file 1xzJuLkAdDhGDC2Rc-yQZDH-R8vlVvHHi). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-QE-0006Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration. Existing later corrections retained; no evidence or assessment status changed.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-QE-0007Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored BN-001, RM-001, AT-001 from FR_QE_0007_quantum_advantage_practical.html (Drive file 1qCC0WcnKOMiutuuqh5ah_6wXPN0X2SQs). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-QE-0008Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, AT-001 from FR_QE_0008_error_correction_scaling.html (Drive file 1b6n8s4qZ8FE08RIymo-4e-kpFvQ49Nyz). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AI-0001Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, AT-001; lineage 2017–20, 2022, 2023, 2024 from FR_AI_0001_LLM_reasoning_generalisation.html (Drive file 1P9qpi6wq4V6nyn4ZpgqiYiz-cVrl9pIq). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AI-0002Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, AT-001; lineage 2020–22, 2022–23, 2023–24, 2024 from FR_AI_0002_LLM_knowledge_work_utility.html (Drive file 1kmjQHLUxpNKFNStSoFKR-AE7P-ogFAIZ). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AI-0003Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, AT-001; lineage 2017–20 from FR_AI_0003_RLHF_preference_generalisation.html (Drive file 17k4GkTxHeauxh-Tg-Yxir8gCBNF1ymYa). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AI-0004Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, AT-001 from FR_AI_0004_scaling_emergent_performance.html (Drive file 1k1YV18ZZDTs7emO7mBXZL103gIvoIsQV). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AI-0005Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, BN-001, BN-002, AT-001 from FR_AI_0005_AGI_through_scaling.html (Drive file 1V4eVHRvuMV4gNZw4kVegbZGph1vcvvTn). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AI-0006Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, BN-001, AT-001 from FR_AI_0006_scaling_mechanism_coherence.html (Drive file 1VeNxj-LTcGiSmfmVgFJehKuge1u7Aj37). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AI-0008Normal Record Review of the final MASAI interval-cancer analysis. FRAGMENTING / VS-03 retained, but the positive prospective-deployment pole is materially strengthened. BN-001, AT-001, 2026 lineage and OQ-003 updated to reflect that prospective success is demonstrated in mammography while cross-domain transferability remains unresolved.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-09-06FR-AI-0008Normal Record Review admitted Gommers et al. (2026) final MASAI primary interval-cancer analysis with structured primary provenance. New evidence only; no retroactive repair or replacement of legacy instances.instance_addedA
2026-09-06FR-AI-0008Append-only AS-002 issued after the operator-approved LPR-001-D08 repair. FRAGMENTING / VS-03 retained on a narrower evidential basis. BN-001, RM-001, AT-001, lineage and OQ-003 aligned to the corrected evidence: regulatory authorisation is not treated as uniform prospective validation; distribution shift is documented but not universalised; foundation-model resolution is no longer presumed. Historical AS-001 preserved. The 2026 final MASAI interval-cancer analysis remains outside this repair as a normal Record Review candidate.assessment_and_dependencies_correctedA (subsumed)
2026-09-06FR-AI-0008Operator-approved correction of IN-001 through IN-005. Primary structured provenance added where source fidelity was established. IN-001 bounded to the actual landmark benchmark designs; IN-002 separates device-specific FDA authorisation from prospective-validation claims; IN-003 corrects chronology and bounds the generalisation inference; IN-004 replaces conflated STHLM3/NHS wording with verified MASAI prospective randomised evidence; IN-005 is retained as explicit unsupported legacy provenance rather than retrofitted to substitute evidence. No new scientific evidence admitted through LPR-001.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-06FR-AI-0008Legacy provenance review completed. All five evidence instances examined. Material source-fidelity discrepancies identified in IN-001 through IN-005, so no structured provenance was silently added to those instances. One genuinely new scientific result — the 2026 final MASAI interval-cancer analysis — was identified and held out for normal Record Review rather than admitted through LPR-001. No factual, interpretive, assessment, pressure-state, or verification-stage wording changed. Review marked pending governed correction.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-06FR-AM-0001Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, CM-001; lineage 1991– from FR_MF_0001_cold_fusion_collapse.html (Drive file 1goJsend-Scsoet868GpcTWELGC_ctVfh). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AM-0002Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, IN-001; lineage 1989, 1989–91, 2024 from FR_MF_0002_anomalous_excess_heat.html (Drive file 1qB9Wsdf9b3Trw32dcQHEPPLsrZIH6z14). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AM-0003Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, AT-001 from FR_MF_0003_cuprate_superconductivity_mechanism.html (Drive file 19czOspfLKee1tTark6lti8sr-LBaHObs). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AM-0004Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, AT-001; lineage 2023–24 from FR_MF_0004_commercial_fusion_power.html (Drive file 1agttcKhzYzuekNWnZmYnUnwQ1XzmPp8-). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AM-0005Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored CM-001, RM-001, AT-001; lineage 1986–2010s from FR_MF_0005_room_temp_superconductor_reproducibility.html (Drive file 1tRbrLxtIn7a7DH9AmsIqyFPy-V148Ac7). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-AM-0006Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, BN-001, AT-001 from FR_MF_0006_solid_state_batteries_EV.html (Drive file 1C8JlUzn2qBeHOncW6vAxA98w5g0Qcnju). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-BT-0001Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, RM-002, BN-001, AT-001; lineage 2021–24 from FR_BT_0001_senolytics_lifespan_extension.html (Drive file 1YxRAM6C_mRMC7AbG5C_cM18zujArQxhl). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-BT-0002Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored RM-001, BN-001, AT-001 from FR_BT_0002_epigenetic_reprogramming_age_reversal.html (Drive file 12oQGYiWaYPv8-Je7uQ9gnN_v6IUV5zZ5). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-BT-0003Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored BN-001, RM-001, AT-001 from FR_BT_0003_biological_age_biomarker_prediction.html (Drive file 1JK_i4ftSrQ5UtZWm2Ncv8sd8wykgIaC0). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-06FR-BT-0004Editorial Correction (GP-001), RENDER-PILOT-001 content restoration: restored BN-001 from FR_BT_0004_liquid_biopsy_early_cancer_detection.html (Drive file 1gbY5KwOYxG6sVUv5rRJZUhmCzmS5B0HS). Each damaged value was a verified prefix of the recovered source after the existing FR-MF to FR-AM identifier migration. Restored the omitted remainder using the original converter text normalization; no inferred completion. Existing later corrections retained. Restoration recovers historical wording and does not reaffirm it as the current assessment. Assessments, evidence instances, open questions, claim, status and rendering eligibility unchanged. Source hashes and field receipt: docs/reviews/render-pilot-content-restoration.json; current-assessment compatibility review: docs/reviews/RENDER-PILOT-001-CONTENT-RESTORATION.md.description_restoredD
2026-09-05FR-AI-0007AS-003 appended after the approved LPR-001-D07 bounded correction. Historical AS-001/AS-002 preserved. Current judgement retains FRAGMENTING / VS-03 on the narrower source-faithful basis established by corrected IN-001 through IN-005 and verified IN-006 through IN-009. BN-001, AT-001, lineage, and OQ-002 were aligned to remove dependencies on superseded legacy interpretations.assessment_correctionD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-09-05FR-AI-0007Governed bounded correction applied to IN-001 through IN-005. AlphaFold2 bounded to CASP14 prediction evidence; GNoME separated from the distinct A-Lab synthesis study; AI Scientist conference-review overstatement removed; FunSearch bounded to human-framed program search and verifiable reported results; unsupported IN-005 institutional-restructuring bundle withdrawn and retained as explicit provenance debt. Structured primary sources added where attribution is secure. No new evidence admitted.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-05FR-AI-0007Legacy provenance review completed. All nine evidence instances examined. Structured primary-source provenance added to source-faithful IN-006 through IN-009. Material source-fidelity discrepancies identified in IN-001 through IN-004; IN-005's bundled institutional attribution could not be confidently reconstructed as written. No factual or interpretive wording silently repaired, no new scientific evidence admitted, and no assessment, pressure-state, or verification-stage changes made. Review marked pending governed correction.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-04FR-AI-0006Normal Record Review reassessed FR-AI-0006 after admission of IN-007. Xu's 2026 cross-scale representation-geometry result deepens the continuity/discontinuity ambiguity but does not resolve mechanism identity. FRAGMENTING / VS-03 retained; preprint and replication limitations recorded.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-09-04FR-AI-0006Normal Record Review admitted Xu (2026), arXiv:2605.17084v1: Subspace PGA evidence of scale-dependent predictive representation geometry across seven Pythia models with three cross-family checks. Admitted as new evidence with primary provenance; not used to retrofit unresolved legacy IN-005.instance_addedA
2026-09-04FR-AI-0006AS-003 appended after the approved LPR-001-D06 bounded correction. Historical AS-001/AS-002 preserved. Current judgement retains FRAGMENTING / VS-03 on the narrower source-faithful basis established by corrected IN-001 through IN-006. Affected lineage wording was aligned to the corrected historical evidence; no new evidence instance admitted.assessment_correctionD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-09-04FR-AI-0006Governed bounded correction applied to IN-002 through IN-005. IN-002 aligned to Wei et al. and Michaud et al.; IN-003 bounded to Elhage et al.'s toy-model superposition evidence; IN-004 bounded to Power et al. and Nanda et al.'s small-model grokking evidence; unsupported IN-005 cross-scale geometry claims withdrawn and retained as explicit provenance debt without retrofitted source. No new evidence admitted.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-04FR-AI-0006Legacy provenance review completed. All six evidence instances examined. IN-001 and IN-006 structured provenance verified. Material source-fidelity discrepancies identified in IN-002, IN-003, and IN-004; IN-005 legacy attribution could not be confidently reconstructed and was left unchanged. No new scientific evidence admitted and no assessment, pressure-state, or verification-stage changes made. Review marked pending governed correction.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-03FR-AI-0005AS-003 appended after the approved LPR-001-D05 bounded correction. Historical AS-001/AS-002 preserved. The unsupported IN-006 target-migration event is withdrawn from the current evidential basis; FRAGMENTING / VS-03 retained on the narrower basis of continued capability gains plus unresolved path-definition and scaling-regime change. Separate downstream consistency repair remains required for mechanism, lineage, and open-question wording that inherited the target-migration premise.assessment_correctionD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-09-03FR-AI-0005Governed bounded correction applied to IN-001 through IN-007. Source representations aligned to Brown et al., GPT-4 Technical Report, Sutskever's 2024 remarks, OpenAI o1, Villalobos et al., OpenAI Charter, and Snell et al. Structured sources[] added; unsupported bundled claims removed or bounded. No new evidence instance admitted.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-03FR-AI-0005Legacy provenance review completed. All seven evidence instances examined. Material source-fidelity discrepancies identified across the legacy evidence trail; no factual or interpretive wording silently repaired and no new scientific evidence admitted. Review marked pending governed correction.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-02FR-AI-0004AS-003 issued as the governed append-only assessment correction after LPR-001-D04. It narrows historical source interpretations while retaining FRAGMENTING / VS-03. AS-001 and AS-002 remain unchanged as historical judgements; no new evidence admitted.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-09-02FR-AI-0004Governed bounded correction applied to IN-001, IN-004, IN-005, IN-006, and IN-007. Structured primary-source provenance added; unsupported claims about unseen-task proof, universal continuity, benchmark-specific contamination/saturation, 2024 dating of Chinchilla, and bundled test-time-compute consensus/saturation claims were removed or bounded. IN-002 and IN-003 remain as verified during the original provenance pass.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-02FR-AI-0004Legacy provenance review completed. Structured provenance added to IN-002 and IN-003. Material source-fidelity discrepancies identified in IN-001, IN-004, IN-005, IN-006, and IN-007 and left unchanged pending governed correction approval. No new scientific evidence admitted; assessments, pressure state, and verification stage unchanged.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-09-01FR-AI-0003Append-only assessment correction issued after the governed IN-001 through IN-006 provenance repair. AS-003 narrows unsupported capability-outpacing and recovery language while retaining FRAGMENTING / VS-03. AS-001 and AS-002 remain unchanged as historical assessments. LPR-001-D03 discrepancies are now corrected and provenance repair is complete; no new evidence admitted.assessment_correctionD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-09-01FR-AI-0003Governed bounded correction applied to IN-001 through IN-006 after LPR-001-D03 approval. Legacy source representations were aligned to Ouyang et al., Wei et al., Perez/Sharma, Bai et al., Scheurer et al., and Burns et al.; structured sources[] added. IDs, dates, vectors, AS-001, AS-002, pressure state, and verification stage unchanged. Post-correction consistency check identifies historical assessment wording that depends on superseded IN-004/IN-005/IN-006 interpretations; assessment correction remains separately pending and is not silently applied.provenance_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-09-01FR-AI-0003Legacy provenance review completed. Structured provenance added to IN-007, IN-008, and IN-009. Material source-fidelity discrepancies identified in legacy IN-001 through IN-006 and left unchanged pending governed correction approval. No new evidence admitted; assessment and verification stage unchanged.provenance_reviewUNKNOWN
2026-08-31FR-AI-0001Legacy provenance review completed. IN-001, IN-002, IN-004 and IN-005 corrected for source fidelity and enriched with structured sources[]; IN-003 remains deliberately unenriched because its intended source could not be confidently established. No assessment or evidence-state change.provenance_review_completedD
2026-08-30FR-AI-0002LPR-001 Day 1 completion recorded after the bounded correction of IN-001, IN-002 and IN-004. The marker records review completion separately from repair outcome so the deterministic oldest/never-reviewed queue can operate. No evidence instance, assessment, Pressure State or Verification Stage was added or changed by this marker.provenance_review_completedD
2026-08-30FR-AI-0002LPR-001 Day 1 Editorial Correction. Corrected the three linked legacy evidence descriptions and added canonical structured provenance. IN-001, IN-002 and IN-004 retain their identifiers, dates and vectors. AS-001 and AS-002 remain preserved; current Pressure State ESCALATING and Verification Stage VS-02 are unchanged.reference_correctedD
2026-08-29FR-QE-0004PA-002 Provenance Enrichment: structured sources[] added to IN-008; evidentiary prose and assessment unchanged.provenance_enrichedUNKNOWN
2026-08-29FR-QE-0007PA-002 Provenance Enrichment: structured sources[] added to IN-001 and IN-002; evidentiary prose and assessment unchanged.provenance_enrichedUNKNOWN
2026-08-29FR-AI-0001PA-002 Provenance Enrichment: structured sources[] added to IN-005 and IN-006; evidentiary prose and assessment unchanged.provenance_enrichedUNKNOWN
2026-08-29FR-AI-0006Added primary Transformer Circuits and arXiv provenance for Olsson et al. (2022) after bounded source review.provenance_enrichedUNKNOWN
2026-08-29FR-AI-0006Editorial Correction: aligned IN-001 and matching 2022 lineage wording with Olsson et al.'s stated evidence strength. No new evidence instance and no reassessment; FRAGMENTING / VS-03 remains current under AS-002.editorial_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-08-29FR-AI-0006PA-005 review: FRAGMENTING / VS-03 retained after admission of IN-006.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-08-29FR-AI-0006PA-005: Yang et al. ICML 2025 cross-scale symbolic-mechanism evidence admitted with structured provenance.instance_addedA
2026-08-29FR-AI-0007IN-009 appended — The Station autonomous mathematical discovery study (arXiv:2608.23691v1), authorised through Post-Scout flag RR-2026-08-29-01. SUPPORTIVE instance evidence for autonomous research direction and scientific judgment within a human-defined shared goal. Independent validation remains incomplete; the autonomous problem-identification boundary (BN-001/OQ-001/AT-001) is unchanged. No assessment issued; pressureState FRAGMENTING, verificationStage VS-03, mechanisms, and openQuestions unchanged.instance_appendedA
2026-08-29FR-AM-0006AS-004 issued after bounded VS-03 Classification Review. Pressure state ESCALATING retained; Verification Stage corrected from VS-03 to VS-02 because METI supply-plan certification is not independent claim-level technical audit.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-08-29FR-AM-0006Editorial Correction: replaced the unsupported October 7, 2025 government production-approval characterisation with the substantiated September 6, 2024 METI certification of Toyota’s battery development and production plan; clarified the separate October 8, 2025 Sumitomo material-development agreement. Evidentiary direction unchanged.editorial_correctionUNKNOWN
2026-08-29FR-AM-0006AS-003 issued after bounded FR-AM-0006 Record Review. Pressure state ESCALATING and VS-03 sustained; IN-007 does not meet the commercial-operation attractor.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-08-29FR-AM-0006PA-004 operational provenance trial: QuantumScape automated pilot-line scale-up evidence admitted with canonical sources[] captured at admission.instance_addedA
2026-08-29FR-BT-0002PA-006 opportunistic legacy provenance enrichment. Primary Life Biosciences IND announcement and ClinicalTrials.gov registration verified the existing IN-006 event; description and evidentiary interpretation unchanged.provenance_enrichedUNKNOWN
2026-08-29FR-BT-0002PA-006 reassessment after first human dosing. ESCALATING / VS-02 retained: human testing is operational, but no human outcome evidence has been reported.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-08-29FR-BT-0002First participant dosed in ER-100 Phase 1 trial admitted with structured provenance at admission under PA-006.instance_addedA
2026-08-28FR-QE-0007GP-001 provenance and description correction following the bounded three-record source/DOI audit. IN-005 had conflated the superconducting processor substrate with the simulated phenomenon and incorrectly attributed a superconducting-material phase transition to Mi et al. The instance now states the verified time-crystal, small-molecule/quantum-magnet and simplified hydrogen-chain/iron-crystal results. AS-001 and AS-002 remain preserved; the correction does not alter their conjunction analysis. Pressure State FRAGMENTING and Verification Stage VS-03 are explicitly retained.reference_correctedD
2026-08-28FR-QE-0007AS-002 issued following the bounded FR-QE-0007 impact review. Pressure State FRAGMENTING and Verification Stage VS-03 retained. Quantum Echoes narrows the separation between beyond-classical performance and practical relevance, but the two thresholds remain demonstrated in different experimental regimes; Google-affiliated follow-up analysis is not treated as independent replication. No existing assessment, instance, mechanism, open question, or related record modified.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-08-28FR-QE-0007IN-006 appended — Google Quantum Echoes and the connected molecular-geometry OTOC programme. Classified as partial evidence: reproducible beyond-classical performance and practical application relevance are both present within the programme but not at the same demonstrated scale. Instance logged before AS-002; no state or verification-stage change at this step.instance_appendedA
2026-08-28FR-AI-0009GP-001 provenance correction following the bounded three-record source/DOI audit. Stable publication identifiers were added to every evidence instance. IN-003 is explicitly identified as a corporate research announcement without a DOI; IN-008 carries its own CaliBench reference because it post-dates AS-001. No evidence description, interpretation, assessment, pressureState, verificationStage, mechanism, or open question changed.reference_correctedD
2026-08-28FR-BT-0004GP-001 provenance and description correction following the bounded three-record source/DOI audit. IN-003, RM-001, AT-001 and OQ-001 now distinguish the trial's actual late-stage-incidence primary endpoint from later mortality evidence. IN-005 records the approximately $7.1bn transaction and both EU and US enforcement history. IN-006 identifies JCO LBA100 as a conference-supplement abstract rather than a full article. AS-001 and AS-002 remain unchanged as append-only historical assessments; their mortality-endpoint wording must be read with this correction. Current Pressure State FRAGMENTING and Verification Stage VS-04 remain unchanged.reference_correctedD
2026-08-27FR-AM-0004IN-007 added following bounded FCIF audit: Helical Fusion / NIFS UROCOIC double-pancake HTS coil result, first announced in 2025 and peer-reviewed in August 2026. Classified as supportive pre-threshold engineering evidence; no pressure-state or verification-stage change.instance_loggedA
2026-08-25FR-AM-0007Initial governed assessment logged for the admission decision: ESCALATING / VS-03. This mutation records the already-issued AS-001 and does not change its substance, pressure state, or verification stage.assessment_issuedA
2026-08-25FR-AM-0007Canonical openedDate added as the actual FCIF admission date. The field remains operationally required for Record Directory sorting even though opened-date display was removed from the public UI. No evidentiary or assessment change.opened_date_addedUNKNOWN
2026-08-25FR-AM-0007Schema-shape correction after prerender validation exposed that relatedRecords requires id, relationship, and note fields. FR-AM-0003 and FR-AM-0005 relationships are preserved; no claim, evidence, assessment, pressure state, or verification stage changed.related_records_correctedUNKNOWN
2026-08-25FR-AM-0007Initial evidence trail logged at admission following the bounded FCIF Admission Review: IN-001 through IN-004 reconstruct the pressure-quench superconductivity trajectory from the early Sb/FeSe demonstrations through the March 2026 Hg1223 result.instances_loggedA
2026-08-25FR-AM-0007FR-AM-0007 admitted following bounded FCIF Admission Review. Initial state ESCALATING; verification stage VS-03. Scope limited to retention of pressure-induced or pressure-enhanced superconducting states at ambient pressure.record_createdA
2026-08-22FR-AI-0009IN-008 CaliBench added following RR-2026-08-22-01 Post-Scout Human Record Review and explicit operator authorization. The approved action was INSTANCE only; AS-001, ESCALATING pressure state and VS-02 verification stage remain unchanged.instance_addedA
2026-08-21FR-BT-0005Admission diagnosis: ESCALATING / VS-03. Living-human renal replacement is demonstrated, while durability, rejection control and prospective reproducibility remain unresolved.diagnosis_heldA (subsumed)
2026-08-21FR-BT-0005BN-001, RM-001, RM-002, BN-002 and AT-001 recorded from the admission evidence package.mechanisms_recordedA (subsumed)
2026-08-21FR-BT-0005AS-001 issued. Pressure State: ESCALATING. Verification Stage: VS-03.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-08-21FR-BT-0005IN-001 through IN-007 admitted as the initial two-sided evidence set.instances_loggedA
2026-08-21FR-BT-0005FR-BT-0005 admitted following bounded PROG-BT coverage review and formal material-commitment reconstruction.record_createdA
2026-08-19FR-AI-0009Admission diagnosis: ESCALATING / VS-02. Positive bounded transfer evidence and direct reliability counterevidence are both substantive.diagnosis_heldA (subsumed)
2026-08-19FR-AI-0009BN-001, RM-001, RM-002 and AT-001 recorded from the admission evidence package.mechanisms_recordedA (subsumed)
2026-08-19FR-AI-0009AS-001 issued. Pressure State: ESCALATING. Verification Stage: VS-02.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-08-19FR-AI-0009IN-001 through IN-007 admitted as the initial two-sided evidence set.instances_loggedA
2026-08-19FR-AI-0009FR-AI-0009 admitted following bounded AI Programme Coverage Review and formal claim-type/material-commitment admission gate.record_createdA
2026-08-17FR-QE-0004AS-002 issued during OHR-2026-09 catch-up review to close the evidence-assessment gap through IN-009. IN-007, IN-008, and IN-009 strengthen the engineering and architectural evidence but do not resolve the decisive d=11-and-above scaling question. Pressure State remains RESOLVING; Verification Stage remains VS-04; mechanisms and open questions remain unchanged.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-08-17FR-QE-0006AS-002 issued during OHR-2026-09 catch-up review to close the evidence-assessment gap created by IN-006. Pressure State remains ESCALATING; Verification Stage remains VS-02.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-08-17FR-AI-0002AS-002 issued during OHR-2026-09 catch-up review to close the evidence-assessment gap created by IN-007. ORCA-bench strengthens the existing contesting evidence at the low-supervision agentic boundary but does not overturn bounded, human-reviewed knowledge-work utility. Pressure State remains ESCALATING; Verification Stage remains VS-02; mechanisms and open questions remain unchanged.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-08-08FR-QE-0004IN-009 appended following operator approval of Post-Scout Human Record Review flag 2026-08-08-01. The D-Wave dual-rail entangling-gate result (Nature, DOI 10.1038/s41586-026-10822-y) is logged as bounded SUPPORTIVE component-level evidence for the scalable-architecture element of the claim. It preserves a favourable erasure-biased error hierarchy during an essential two-qubit operation, but does not demonstrate a logical qubit, integrated below-threshold error correction, measured logical suppression with increasing code distance, d=11-and-above scaling, or realistic full-system operation; favourable code-distance behaviour remains simulation-derived. Instance-level append only; no assessment issued; pressureState RESOLVING, verificationStage VS-04, mechanisms, openQuestions, and new-record disposition unchanged.instance_appendedA
2026-08-01FR-AI-0002IN-007 appended — ORCA-bench (arXiv:2607.28545v1), authorised through Post-Scout flag 2026-08-01-02. Bounded CONTESTING evidence strengthens the existing low-supervision agentic boundary with operational root-cause-analysis measurements. Instance only: AS-001 remains current; Pressure State ESCALATING, Verification Stage VS-02, mechanisms, and open questions unchanged. No new assessment issued.instance_appendedA
2026-08-01FR-AI-0007AS-002 issued following operator-approved Post-Scout flag 2026-08-01-01. Pressure State FRAGMENTING and Verification Stage VS-03 retained. The assessment now distinguishes autonomous problem identification from scientific judgment after a problem is supplied; IN-008 establishes bounded contesting evidence on the latter. No existing assessment, instance, mechanism, or open question modified.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-08-01FR-AI-0007IN-008 appended — open-ended AI research shadow evaluation (arXiv:2607.27191v1), authorised through Post-Scout flag 2026-08-01-01. Bounded CONTESTING evidence: agents completed substantial research engineering but failed the tested open-ended scientific-judgment task. Instance logged before AS-002; no prior corpus content modified.instance_appendedA
2026-07-28FR-QE-0002GP-001 Editorial Correction. Incorrect publication metadata — IN-003 cited the wrong journal for Yarkoni et al. 2022; correct journal is Reports on Progress in Physics. Surfaced during FR-QE-0002 Identity and Continuity Review, Revision 3 (Baseline Sufficiency Assessment), confirmed as an admission-era error present verbatim in the recovered pre-deployment source. No evidence, interpretation, pressureState, verificationStage, assessment, or open question substance changed.reference_correctedD
2026-07-28FR-QE-0002GP-001 Editorial Correction. IN-002's description mischaracterised the Denchev et al. 2016 benchmark as simulation-task evidence; the contemporaneous source frames it as a "quantum enhanced optimization heuristic" tested on a crafted combinatorial problem. Corrected to restore the contemporaneous framing. This wording error was cosmetic to the record's own task-class kernel analysis (Terminal Identity and Continuity Finding, §B), which already classified IN-002 as engaging the optimisation-task kernel using the correct framing — this correction does not alter that finding. No evidence, interpretation, pressureState, verificationStage, assessment, or open question substance changed.description_correctedUNKNOWN
2026-07-26FR-QE-0002OQ-006 formally entered per Terminal Identity and Continuity Finding §C precision requirement (whether "practical" is part of the identity-bearing kernel or only an evaluative standard applied to it). Resolved: element of the settled kernel (Terminal Finding §A.2), with the standard for operationalising it left open — an evaluative-standard question, not an identity question. Does not reopen or alter the ratified Terminal Identity and Continuity Finding or Pressure State Reassessment.open_question_addedUNKNOWN
2026-07-26FR-QE-0002AS-002 appended following ratified Identity and Continuity Finding (IDENTITY PRESERVED AS A COMPOUND CLAIM) and Pressure State Reassessment (FRAGMENTING REMAINS WARRANTED — RE-GROUNDED). AS-001 preserved unchanged.assessment_reissuedA (subsumed)
2026-07-22FR-QE-0001Append-only canonical reassessment issued after completion of the governed FR-QE-0001 inquiry. Institutional verdict: UNRESOLVED AT THE ORIGINAL COMPARISON POINT; LATER SUPERSEDED. Pressure State changed from FRAGMENTING to STABILISING because successor claims, including Willow, are outside the admitted claim's material commitments and the remaining uncertainty is bounded. Verification Stage changed from VS-03 to VS-04 under the canonical evidence-depth semantics because independent classical work directly reproduced and ultimately counter-performed the constitutive benchmark comparator. VS-04 is claim-level adversarial replication, not independent reproduction of Sycamore hardware. AS-001 and all earlier history remain preserved.assessment_issuedA
2026-07-22FR-QE-0001S4 was ratified as the operative reconstruction-era baseline on 2026-07-21. The Current Canonical Conformity Check found S5b materially non-conforming due to undocumented S4-to-S5 conversion divergence. FR-QE-0001 was corrected in place through a fidelity-checked transcription of S4. S5 (586ac0ccd7ba38d0389c12f5031785ecfc5c24de) and final pre-realignment S5b (45a2ad096b178f115083e495ff892253db2a404e; unchanged FR-QE-0001 file Git blob e374f039c969ae0b8e80d853f563e54ef7577d6a) remain preserved in Git history and the governance audit trail. This act does not recover the lost 2024 admission. No claim-type, temporality, continuity, pressure-state correctness or verdict determination was made, and S4's FRAGMENTING assessment was not newly reviewed, reaffirmed or ratified.canonical_baseline_realignedUNKNOWN
2026-07-17FR-AI-0007IN-007 appended — Distributed Denial of Science (arXiv:2607.10712v1). Bounded CONTESTING instance on the correctness component: under the tested adversarial retrieval setting, correctness in autonomous scientific workflows is conditional on evidential provenance. The existential claim and previously demonstrated correct discoveries are preserved; the autonomous problem-identification boundary (BN-001/OQ-001/AT-001) is unchanged. No assessment issued; pressureState FRAGMENTING, verificationStage VS-03, mechanisms, and openQuestions unchanged. The separately authorised NEW RECORD PATH component is not implemented by this mutation.instance_appendedA
2026-07-14FR-QE-0004IN-007 and IN-008 appended, both SUPPORTIVE, from Frontline Scout reports 2026-07-03 (IN-007 — qLDPC breakeven on trapped-ion, arXiv:2606.06455, IonQ-affiliated, interested party) and 2026-07-11 (IN-008 — real-time RL recalibration, Nature, peer-reviewed). Surfaced during evidence-gap review as non-duplicate evidence stranded in the Scout archive. The two supportive contributions are distinct in kind and the distinction is preserved in prose: IN-007 bears on the threshold/breakeven result itself; IN-008 bears on sustained operation within the scalable-architecture component. Together they enrich the record without resolving its remaining scale (d=11 and above, OQ-001) and replication questions. Instance-level append only; no assessment issued; pressureState RESOLVING, verificationStage VS-04, mechanisms, and openQuestions unchanged. IN-007's source retains its separate Scout FCIF-candidate status; this instance does not pre-decide that.instances_appendedUNKNOWN
2026-07-14FR-QE-0006IN-006 appended — composed logical Clifford operations via lattice surgery (arXiv:2607.01473).instance_appendedA
2026-07-14FR-AI-0003AS-002 issued. Pressure state FRAGMENTING retained; verificationStage VS-03 unchanged. Records the first direct empirical pressure on OQ-001 (via IN-007) and the unresolved action-authority boundary question. Instances IN-007/IN-008/IN-009 logged first (M-008); AS-002 issued second. No existing assessment, instance, mechanism, or open question modified; OQ-004 sharpened within AS-002's current judgement rather than retroactively altered. No new record opened.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-07-14FR-AI-0003Three evidence instances appended from Frontline Scout reports 2026-07-03 (IN-007 — ROGUE, arXiv:2606.00341; IN-008 — Agent Safety Is Action Alignment, arXiv:2606.28739) and 2026-07-05 (IN-009 — public/off-record divergence study). Surfaced during evidence-gap review as non-duplicate evidence stranded in the Scout archive. Instance-level append only at this step; pressureState, verificationStage, mechanisms, and openQuestions unchanged.instances_appendedUNKNOWN
2026-07-14FR-AI-0007Operator correction: IN-006's vector must use the controlled vocabulary token NEUTRAL. The prior value encoded an explanatory phrase into the vector slot, introducing a non-vocabulary live shorthand; it is retracted. The constrained-autonomy nuance (constrained generation within a human-framed, human-prior-encoded space; problem-identification boundary untouched; competitive-not-superior) remains stated in IN-006's description, which is its correct location. Classification unchanged — NEUTRAL as recorded in M-009. No other field altered.vector_correctedUNKNOWN
2026-07-14FR-AI-0007IN-006 appended — Structured Concept Evolution (arXiv:2606.24808), surfaced from Frontline Scout report 2026-07-03 during evidence-gap review as non-duplicate evidence stranded in the Scout archive. Instance-level append only, classified NEUTRAL: constrained autonomous generation within a human-framed, human-prior-encoded space; the decisive problem-identification boundary (BN-001/OQ-001/AT-001) is untouched and competitive performance is not established as superior. No assessment issued; pressureState FRAGMENTING, verificationStage VS-03, mechanisms, and openQuestions unchanged. Recurrence observed but not institutionalised here: third constrained-domain instance of the IN-002/IN-004 autonomous-generation pattern, left for later cross-programme review.instance_appendedA
2026-07-09FR-QE-0004Editorial Correction (GP-001): RM-001 and AT-001 mechanism descriptions, and the 1995–97 and 1998–2019 lineage.items entries, were truncated (500-char convert-records.js defect — same defect class as RELEASE-033's AS-001 restorations, which did not cover mechanisms[] or lineage.items[]). Full text restored verbatim from the canonical source HTML (FR_QE_0004_below_threshold_error_correction.html, Drive). No wording added or altered beyond restoring the truncated remainder; no other field changed. Initiated ahead of RENDER-PILOT-001 (public rendering of mechanisms[] and lineage.items[] would otherwise have shipped mid-sentence truncation to the public page).description_restoredD
2026-07-09FR-QE-0004Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-006 description reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-QE-0005Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-006 description reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-AI-0001Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-006 description reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-AI-0002Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-004 description reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-AI-0003Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-002 description reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-AI-0004Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-007 description reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-AI-0007Editorial Correction (GP-001): OQ-002 incorrectly cited 'the existing RN-004 taxonomy of act types' and 'Option D in the updated RN-004.' Investigation (2026-07-09) established that the retired RN-004 (Trajectory Vocabulary — Endurance/Stagnation, retired 2026-07-07) is a different document from the act-type taxonomy (commercial commitment / regulatory preparation / community standards tightening) OQ-002 actually refers to; the latter was never filed as a numbered Review Note. OQ-002 reworded to refer to the taxonomy descriptively rather than by a document label that both never existed for this taxonomy and, independently, now names a retired document about an unrelated subject. Note for the record: M-006 (this same file) removed a parallel 'in the sense of RN-004' reference from IN-005 on the stated rationale that RN-004 was retired; that rationale conflated the two RN-004s, but M-006's action (removing the label) is unaffected — IN-005 is correct with no numbered-document reference, for the reason established here rather than the reason originally given.reference_correctedD
2026-07-09FR-AI-0007Editorial Correction (GP-001): BN-001, BN-002, and AT-001 mechanism descriptions, and the 2023 lineage.items entry, were truncated (500-char convert-records.js defect — same defect class as RELEASE-033's AS-001 restorations, which did not cover mechanisms[] or lineage.items[]). Full text restored verbatim from the canonical source HTML (FR_AI_0007_autonomous_scientific_discovery.html, Drive). No wording added or altered beyond restoring the truncated remainder; no other field changed. Initiated ahead of RENDER-PILOT-001 (public rendering of mechanisms[] and lineage.items[] would otherwise have shipped mid-sentence truncation to the public page). OQ-002's separate stale-reference issue (flagged 2026-07-09) is NOT addressed by this entry — see flag to operator.description_restoredD
2026-07-09FR-AI-0007Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-005 description reordered per EP-001 (closing synthesis moved to opening), and stale 'in the sense of RN-004' reference removed — RN-004 was retired 2026-07-07. No other wording changed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-AI-0008Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-002, IN-003, IN-004, IN-005 descriptions reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-AM-0004Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-003, IN-006 descriptions reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-AM-0005Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-006 description reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-AM-0006Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-001, IN-003, IN-006 descriptions reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-BT-0001Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-004, IN-005 descriptions reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-09FR-BT-0002Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-003 description reordered per EP-001 — existing closing synthesis sentence moved to opening, no wording added or removed.description_reorderedUNKNOWN
2026-07-08FR-QE-0003Per Stuart's confirmation, the experimentalAnnotations[] pilot container (M-009) is retired and removed from this record. Its content is fully superseded by REN-001 (M-010), which formalises the same observation as a mature FCIF object. Removal carries zero migration cost, as documented in the pilot's own code comment (see FrontierRecord.jsx, record.experimentalAnnotations ?? []); no other record or component depends on this field. This is a deletion of pilot scaffolding, not an editorial correction under GP-001 and not a removal of assessments[] or other append-only evidentiary history.experimental_annotations_retiredUNKNOWN
2026-07-08FR-QE-0003realizationNotes field added to schema. REN-001 formalises, as a mature FCIF object, the same observation raised informally in the 2026-07-07 experimentalAnnotations pilot entry (M-009): evidentiary strengthening without corresponding realization progress. The experimentalAnnotations entry is left in place under append-only discipline and not deleted; its retirement, now that a mature schema field covers the same ground, is a decision for Stuart. Corpus Review — Realization Note Candidates (v2).realization_note_addedUNKNOWN
2026-07-08FR-QE-0005Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-004 and OQ-002 referred to the stale identifier FR-MF-0004 for the Helion/Microsoft fusion contract. Corrected to FR-AM-0004 following the FR-MF-* → FR-AM-* programme identifier migration (see FR-AM-0004 M-007). No evidence, interpretation, pressureState, verificationStage, assessment, or open question substance changed.reference_correctedD
2026-07-08FR-QE-0005realizationNotes field added to schema. REN-001: fault-tolerant hardware scale/depth/overhead dependency distinguished from algorithmic and resource-estimate evidence. Corpus Review — Realization Note Candidates (v2).realization_note_addedUNKNOWN
2026-07-08FR-QE-0006Editorial Correction (GP-001): stale PROG-MF identifier corrected to PROG-AM.reference_correctedD
2026-07-08FR-QE-0008Editorial Correction (GP-001): OQ-001 referred to the stale identifier PROG-MF. Corrected to PROG-AM following the FR-MF-* → FR-AM-* programme identifier migration. No evidence, interpretation, pressureState, verificationStage, assessment, or open question substance changed.reference_correctedD
2026-07-08FR-AM-0004realizationNotes field added to schema. REN-001: plant-scale engineering, tritium-breeding infrastructure, and licensing dependencies distinguished from fusion-gain evidence. Corpus Review — Realization Note Candidates (v2).realization_note_addedUNKNOWN
2026-07-08FR-AM-0005Editorial Correction (GP-001): the lineage entry and OQ-001, OQ-002, and OQ-003 referred to the stale identifiers FR-MF-0001, FR-MF-0003, and FR-MF-0004 (four occurrences total). Corrected to FR-AM-0001, FR-AM-0003, and FR-AM-0004 following the FR-MF-* → FR-AM-* programme identifier migration. No evidence, interpretation, pressureState, verificationStage, assessment, or open question substance changed.reference_correctedD
2026-07-08FR-AM-0006realizationNotes field added to schema. REN-001: manufacturing-process scale-up distinguished from underlying electrolyte/cell-chemistry evidence. Corpus Review — Realization Note Candidates (v2).realization_note_addedUNKNOWN
2026-07-08FR-BT-0002Editorial Correction (GP-001): OQ-003 referred to the stale identifiers FR-MF-0001, FR-MF-0002, and PROG-MF. Corrected to FR-AM-0001, FR-AM-0002, and PROG-AM following the FR-MF-* → FR-AM-* programme identifier migration. No evidence, interpretation, pressureState, verificationStage, assessment, or open question substance changed.reference_correctedD
2026-07-07FR-QE-0003Added experimentalAnnotations[] — a pilot, non-schema-permanent container for editorial observations distinct from assessments[] and assessorNote. Status: experimental, under institutional review. Does not assert a pressureState or verificationStage change; assessments[] and its append-only history are untouched. First entry records that the claim's evidentiary trajectory is strengthening while realization-relevant enabling capabilities (per this record's own BN-001/RM-001) show no corresponding progress. The container and its rendering may be removed in a future release without migration if the pilot does not prove useful.experimental_annotations_addedD
2026-07-03FR-QE-0003Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-004 and OQ-002 incorrectly cited FR-QE-0001 as containing evidence for Microsoft's topological qubit programme. FR-QE-0001 concerns Google Sycamore / random circuit sampling and contains no such content; the corpus currently has no dedicated Frontier Record for this programme. Corrected in both locations to state this accurately. IN-005's separate, correct reference to FR-QE-0001 (Willow's quantum-simulation instance) was reviewed and left unchanged. No evidence, interpretation, pressureState, verificationStage, assessment, or open question substance changed.reference_correctedD
2026-07-03FR-QE-0004Editorial Correction (GP-001): IN-005 and OQ-002 incorrectly cited FR-QE-0001 as containing evidence for Microsoft's topological qubit programme. FR-QE-0001 concerns Google Sycamore / random circuit sampling and contains no such content; the corpus currently has no dedicated Frontier Record for this programme. Corrected in both locations to state this accurately. No evidence, interpretation, pressureState, verificationStage, assessment, or open question substance changed.reference_correctedD
2026-07-03FR-QE-0004IN-006 added — Legg et al. Nature critique and Microsoft response, bearing on IN-005's pending-verification status. Initiation: Evidence Gap Scan Pilot 001 (Candidate 1). Scope: instance-level only; no Assessment issued; pressureState, verificationStage, and openQuestions unchanged.instance_appendedA
2026-06-29FR-QE-0005OQ-004 added: pace of resource-estimate revision as a possible evidence pattern in its own right.open_question_raisedA
2026-06-29FR-QE-0005AS-002 issued following targeted reassessment of single-assessment records (Homepage v2 scoping side-effect). Pressure state unchanged: ESCALATING. New evidence (IN-006) revises the resource-estimate trajectory but crosses no claim threshold.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-06-29FR-QE-0005IN-006 added: Gidney (2025) and 2026 follow-on resource-estimate reductions for RSA-2048 and elliptic-curve cryptography.instances_loggedA
2026-06-29FR-AI-0004OQ-004 added: whether the claim statement's scope should be revisited now that a second scaling axis (test-time compute) has emerged.open_question_raisedA
2026-06-29FR-AI-0004AS-002 issued following targeted reassessment of single-assessment records. Pressure state unchanged: FRAGMENTING. New evidence (IN-007) adds a genuinely new mechanism (test-time compute) not anticipated by the original claim statement.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-06-29FR-AI-0004IN-007 added: test-time compute / reasoning models (o1/o3, DeepSeek-R1) as a second scaling axis, plus 2025–26 field consensus on inference-driven progress.instances_loggedA
2026-06-29FR-AI-0005OQ-004 added: whether sustained multi-year fragmentation without convergence should itself be treated as evidence toward dissolution.open_question_raisedA
2026-06-29FR-AI-0005AS-002 issued following targeted reassessment of single-assessment records. Pressure state unchanged: FRAGMENTING. New evidence (IN-007) confirms continuation of the three-way fragmentation rather than resolving it in either direction.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-06-29FR-AI-0005IN-007 added: 2025–26 maturation of the scaling-plateau debate and continued frontier-lab capital commitment to the original training-scale path.instances_loggedA
2026-06-29FR-AM-0004OQ-004 added: SPARC's 2026 net-energy target makes OQ-001's resolution-criteria question time-sensitive rather than hypothetical.open_question_raisedA
2026-06-29FR-AM-0004AS-002 issued following targeted reassessment of single-assessment records. Pressure state unchanged: ESCALATING. New evidence (IN-006) is pre-threshold engineering progress; no threshold crossed.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-06-29FR-AM-0004IN-006 added: SPARC assembly, General Fusion first-plasma, DOE commercialisation roadmap (all 2025).instances_loggedA
2026-06-29FR-AM-0005OQ-004 added: whether logging non-threshold-crossing activity on a CLOSED record is a precedent or an over-logging risk.open_question_raisedA
2026-06-29FR-AM-0005AS-002 issued following targeted reassessment of single-assessment records. Pressure state confirmed unchanged: COLLAPSED. Status confirmed unchanged: CLOSED. New evidence (IN-006) does not meet AT-001's reopening condition.assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-06-29FR-AM-0005IN-006 added: nickelate ambient-pressure stabilisation (Feb 2025), 298K high-pressure claim (Nov 2025, unreplicated), PNAS field roadmap (Mar 2026).instances_loggedA
2026-06-29FR-BT-0002OQ-004 added: what a single Phase 1 trial result would or would not satisfy of AT-001's two-part attractor condition.open_question_raisedA
2026-06-29FR-BT-0002AS-002 issued following targeted reassessment of single-assessment records. Pressure state unchanged: ESCALATING. New evidence (IN-006) is the first half of AT-001's named attractor (trial cleared) but not the second (results).assessment_issuedD (resolved 2026-07-05)
2026-06-29FR-BT-0002IN-006 added: Life Biosciences ER-100 FDA IND clearance, first human partial-reprogramming trial, stated Q1 2026 start.instances_loggedA
2026-06-28FR-QE-0003Evidence gap closed. IN-006 logged first; AS-002 issued second. Pressure state sustained as ESCALATING; verificationStage advanced VS-02 → VS-03. OQ-001 remains open because no d=11+ below-threshold result was verified.assessment_issuedA
2026-06-28FR-QE-0003Willow below-threshold evidence reviewed as peer-reviewed surface-code memory result; d=11+ resolution bottleneck remains open.instance_loggedA
2026-06-27FR-AI-0001ASSESSMENT-002 issued. Pressure state: ESCALATING (sustained). Triggering instance: INST-006. Part of RELEASE-004 / TRIAL-001.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-06-27FR-AI-0001INST-006 added (chain-of-thought faithfulness research; OQ-002 sharpened, not closed).instances_loggedA
2026-06-27FR-AM-0006ASSESSMENT-002 issued. Pressure state: ESCALATING (sustained). Triggering instance: INST-006. Part of RELEASE-004 / TRIAL-001.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-06-27FR-AM-0006INST-006 added (2025 timeline window elapsed; 2027–28 target reaffirmed amid renewed delay reports).instances_loggedA
2026-06-27FR-BT-0004ASSESSMENT-002 issued. Pressure state: FRAGMENTING (sustained). Triggering instance: INST-006. Part of RELEASE-004 / TRIAL-001.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2026-06-18FR-AM-0001Programme identity changed. Record identifier migrated to preserve constitutional consistency. FR-MF-* → FR-AM-*. 2026-06-18.record_id_migratedC
2026-06-18FR-AM-0002Programme identity changed. Record identifier migrated to preserve constitutional consistency. FR-MF-* → FR-AM-*. 2026-06-18.record_id_migratedC
2026-06-18FR-AM-0003Programme identity changed. Record identifier migrated to preserve constitutional consistency. FR-MF-* → FR-AM-*. 2026-06-18.record_id_migratedC
2026-06-18FR-AM-0004Programme identity changed. Record identifier migrated to preserve constitutional consistency. FR-MF-* → FR-AM-*. 2026-06-18.record_id_migratedC
2026-06-18FR-AM-0005Programme identity changed. Record identifier migrated to preserve constitutional consistency. FR-MF-* → FR-AM-*. 2026-06-18.record_id_migratedC
2026-06-18FR-AM-0006Programme identity changed. Record identifier migrated to preserve constitutional consistency. FR-MF-* → FR-AM-*. 2026-06-18.record_id_migratedC
2026-06-11FR-QE-0001Original FR-QE-0001 lost. Record reconstructed as mature FCIF version incorporating full claim lifecycle through December 2024. Reconstruction decision: Possibility C (post-case-study version) selected over pre-FCIF reconstruction to produce the canonical anchor record for FCIF Constitutional Case: Google Quantum Advantage. INST-004 through INST-006 added. Assessment reissued at FRAGMENTING. Mechanisms and lineage expanded to reflect complete evidence trajectory.record_reconstructedUNKNOWN
2024-01-15FR-QE-0002RM-001, RM-002 (Resistance); BN-001, BN-002 (Bottleneck) added.mechanisms_recordedA (subsumed)
2024-01-15FR-QE-0002ASSESSMENT-001 issued. Pressure state: FRAGMENTING.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2024-01-15FR-AI-0001RM-001, RM-002 (Resistance); BN-001 (Bottleneck); AT-001 (Attractor) added.mechanisms_recordedA (subsumed)
2024-01-15FR-AI-0001ASSESSMENT-001 issued. Pressure state: ESCALATING. Triggering instance: INST-005.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2024-01-15FR-AI-0001Class-level claim notice added. Definitional dispute recorded as property of frontier.scope_note_addedA (subsumed)
2024-01-15FR-AI-0001FR-AI-0001 opened. Programme: PROG-AI. First record in AI series.record_createdA
2024-01-15FR-AM-0001Observatory note added per collapsed pressure state.collapsed_state_notice_addedA (subsumed)
2024-01-15FR-AM-0001RM-001, RM-002 (Resistance); BN-001 (Bottleneck); CM-001 (Collapse Mechanism) added.mechanisms_recordedA (subsumed)
2024-01-15FR-AM-0001ASSESSMENT-001 (notional, EMERGING), ASSESSMENT-002 (notional, FRAGMENTING), ASSESSMENT-003 (current, COLLAPSED).assessments_issuedA (subsumed)
2024-01-15FR-AM-0001FR-MF-0001 opened. Programme: PROG-MF. First record in materials series.record_createdA
2024-01-01FR-QE-0001Original assessment issued. Pressure state: EMERGING (per FR-QE-0002 post-production review reference). Approximate pre-reconstruction entry preserved from S4.assessment_issuedA (subsumed)
2024-01-01FR-QE-0001INST-001 through INST-003 added (original record scope). Approximate pre-reconstruction entry preserved from S4.instances_loggedA
2024-01-01FR-QE-0001FR-QE-0001 opened. Claim ratified. Programme: PROG-QE. Original record subsequently lost. Approximate pre-reconstruction entry preserved from S4.record_createdA